In-Person Selling Coming Soon!

We’ll be restarting in-person selling, still by appointment only, soon! The following Buffalo Exchange locations are currently taking in-person appointments or are starting soon.

Currently Taking in-Person Selling Appointments:

  • Boston (Allston)
  • Boston (Somerville)
  • Chicago (Andersonville)
  • Chicago (Wicker Park)
  • Pittsburgh
  • Philadelphia
  • Santa Monica
  • San Diego (Hillcrest)
  • Richmond

In-Person Selling Starting Saturday, 9/19:

  • Ventura
  • Melrose
  • Fullerton
  • Sherman Oaks
  • Long Beach

All other Buffalo Exchange locations will start accepting in-person selling appointments on Tuesday, September 22.

In the meantime, you can still schedule drop-off selling appointments. Here’s how it works:

  • Call ahead to schedule a drop-off selling appointment! If you’re new to selling or it’s been awhile, please have your ID on hand when you call so that we can get you set up in our system.
  • Please limit your cleanout to about 50 items & allow them to sit for 24 hours, untouched, before dropping them off.
  • Remember to wear your mask and bring your ID when you drop off your items.
  • Your items will sit overnight before we look through, so it may take up to 3 days to process your items.
  • When we’re done, we’ll call you to let you know your totals. Get paid 30% of our selling price in cash via PayPal or 50% in a Digital Store Card!

Buffalo Exchange Now Buying for Fall, Collage image of pants, sweaters, jackets and other cool-weather items

Buffalo Exchange is Buying for Fall!

Summer flew by and fall is on the way! We’re looking to buy for fall and the best of all seasons. As the temps get cooler, we’re in need of sweaters, lightweight jackets, long-sleeved tees, blouses and button-ups, as well as great denim. Boots, cross-body bags, hats and beanies are definitely on our list as well. Don’t forget that we take jewelry and designer pieces like handbags, wallets and even sunglasses year-round! 

For more information on our current selling protocols, visit If you’re not quite ready to physically venture out to your local Buffalo Exchange, this is a great time to try out our Sell By Mail program! Just request a bag online, fill it with your items and send it out (for FREE!) with UPS. In a few short weeks, we’ll send your cash and trade totals directly to your inbox. We can’t wait to see the amazing things waiting in your closet!

Buffalo Exchange Sell By Mail Buying

Sell Your Clothes Online!

What We’re Looking For

Selling your clothing and accessories is now easier than ever! Simply request a bag online, fill it up and drop it off at UPS. We’ll handle the rest! Our Sell By Mail program is looking for men’s and women’s clothing and accessories. We buy the best of all seasons, all year round, and we accept all sizes. We buy men’s and women’s clothing and accessories in excellent condition, including designer items, popular mall brands, athletic wear, current trends, everyday staples, vintage, and one-of-a-kind pieces. Before you send your items in, take a minute to check them for unintentional holes, spots, or fabric wear. This can make your selling experience more successful! Don’t forget that we take accessories like jewelry and handbags as well as vintage and one-of-a-kind finds!

Items We Need Now:     

  • Men’s and Women’s Tees
  • Blouses
  • Men’s Button-Up Shirts
  • Men’s and Women’s Shorts
  • Tanks
  • Summer Dresses

Brands We Love (Sell By Mail Only!)

We’re looking for brands like Madewell, lululemon, Urban Outfitters, Nordstrom, Topman, Patagonia, Anthropologie, Eileen Fisher, ModCloth, Ralph Lauren, Vince, Adidas, ZARA, Free People, J.Crew, Levi’s, Bonobos, Nike, Eloquii, ASOS, The North Face, PAIGE Denim, Ann Taylor, Penguin, Chico’s, Zumiez, Joe’s Jeans, Dr. Martens, PUMA, Lucky Brand, Gap, Vans, Uniqlo, Lou & Grey, Aritzia, Theory, Velvet, LOFT, Torrid, Everlane, ALLSAINTS, Stop Staring!, Ben Sherman, Reformation, Lazy Oaf, Outdoor Voices, Universal Standard, rag & bone, Tommy Hilfiger, AG Jeans. This is just a sampling of the brands we love, so even if it’s not listed, definitely send it in!

How To Get Started

Request a bag today. Then, find out more about Sell By Mail on our blog!